I had a thought while driving back to the office today after
lunch. (My wife and I share one car, so we trade on our lunches.) Philosophers
were people, just like you and I. Why are they such a fucking big deal?
“20% of what Philosophers say is true, the other 80% is
bullshit,” is what my friend Desmond says, and it’s not a bad maxim to live by,
considering the branding that certain philosophers (or authors) exude over the
course of their tenure—Grant Morrison is convinced that he was abducted by
aliens from the 4th dimension in Kathmandu, an experience which has
begotten the best cosmology and world building to date within the DC Universe.
And this really isn’t about philosophers specifically. It’s
more of a credibility kind of thing. The words we speak, how they impact
people, whether they endure beyond our close circle of friends or disseminate
into the ether of pop-culture and beyond. I imagine that, throughout life, the
layman and learned alike are told that philosophers and other influencers of
culture are these larger than life figures. I’m often guilty of this. See below:
I admit I was angry at first.
I mean take the fucking compliment, guy. But on further reflection, this
appears to be the case, regardless of the critical distance that is maintained
to allow some appreciation of accomplishment. Behind the storyboards, folios,
and canvases are just normal, flesh-and-blood people. We know those we love
(artistically) aren’t gods because Jack Kirby and Ronnie James Dio are dead.
(Though their influences are legion in their respective industries.)
Many work to make a living.
Very few get to make art, without feeling like they are “working.” Dante for
example was one of the few authors in human history to experience the joy and
legacy of his work within his own lifetime. For everyone else that enjoys, possible, posthumous fame, I think this is the case because of
nostalgia.
Consider, for a moment, that in Hellenist
Greece ideas were weighed with greater contemporary influence than they are in
the modern era. There were forums back then specifically for debate and
intellectual pursuits, because it was what their culture valued.
Today (the "modern" world, which could span from the Renaissance to now) this
isn’t the case, and philosophy has been relegated to a niche occupied by
idealists, shutins, and professors. Philosophy is valued because of the nostalgia for the
era in which those ideas were conceived. This can be the only explanation for
why many philosophers never enjoyed their due in life.
After all, death amplifies of
appreciation. The sense of loss and catharsis brought on by death naturally magnifies the
value of someone’s life work as we, the bereaved, try to come to terms with
what has happened. So the issue of critical distance makes sense in this case.
We can’t, personally speaking, appreciate what we are offering because of the
limit imposed by our own vantage point. When we try to do this, the only
foreseeable outcome is looking like a giant piece of shit (a la Kanye West).
So, at least for now, fame
shouldn’t get to our heads. Not until there are worms in them, at least.
>
>>
>
Enraged, curious, stimulated by what you just read?! Comment below! Let's talk about it!