Winsome Dialog For Dummies

During prep time for an onsite meeting recently, I had an interesting encounter with one of my coworkers.

I should say that we align on most things. We are both Christians, we both feel bewildered over the MAGA hijacking of the Christian faith, and our source of Truth (ie. our understanding of the true nature of reality and our place in the space-time universe) is the Gospel. But when Abdul El-Sayed came up in conversation, and I noted the hypocrisy of the heckler he encountered (ambiguously named “Tommy”) at one of his town halls, I discovered an interesting rift between us on the nature of what Islam is now, at the present. The common Western assumption that all Muslims follow a warlike faith, came up. The lack of a willingness to assimilate, came up. The contested opinion of Islam being a “religion of peace” came up. It was the usual talking points, but I felt the conversation lacked the nuance it needed and pushed back a little bit.

Eventually, it concluded when a vendor interrupted us and we had to table it for another time.

But, the interaction got me thinking about things like truth and nuance and all that, and especially about the tempting inclination to make issues overtly binary, rather than appreciate their complexity. I know that, regardless of what you think about Islam, it is necessary to situate it’s founding context in Late Antiquity, where it inherits a lot of the ideas that were dominant at the time. Establishing a state to rival the then ancient, waning powers of Persia and Byzantine Rome, was integral to it’s survival. Evidence of syncretism with Zoroastrianism and revisionist takes on the Talmud (Judaism) and Jesus’s divinity (Christianity) are also present. Granted all that, these days Islam finds itself in a precarious position. The earlier claim that Islam is a “peace-loving” religion, I think, is accurate to say now, in it’s contemporary form, for most adherents residing in Western (and some Eastern) nations. (How much of this is due to Islam being recontextualized within the pluralism that most Western nations practice is something I have heard debated as well.) I would even say, based on what I’ve heard Muslims say about their faith in interfaith dialogues on podcasts like Justin Brierley’s Unbelievable, that they have intimated the need for an internal event equivalent to the Protestant Reformation, so that things like extremism and radicalization can be further relegated to fringe positions within the larger faith itself through doctrinal proclamations. (Also, so that Islam can supersede the historical precedent and need of a caliphate and reduce the role of Sharia law to something more symbolic; much in the same way that the idea of “Christendom,” in my opinion, was eventually rejected—mostly for it’s own artificiality and origins in medieval, political syncretism.) Abdul El-Sayed, in The Weekly Show with John Stewart podcast, said that his allegiance would be to the United States, and it’s constitution, and I believe him when he says that. I’m just not sure that a Muslim jurist (classical or conservative) would agree with that interpretation of the Qur’an presently.

So, despite the fact that I would not agree with most of the exegetical and theological conclusions Islam makes of the Torah and New Testament, my opinion is that we ought not to demonize fellow humans made in the image and likeness of God. This approach is firmly rooted in the New Testament (see 1 Peter 3:15), which itself emerged in a pluralistic world. 1st, 2nd, and 3rd century Christians were well capable of co-inhabiting the world while, at the same time, maintaining their own identity and establishing the truth of the Gospel by simply working it out faithfully. There were no demands made of the Romans by Christians, that they stop abandoning infants to exposure in town dumps. Instead, the Christians adopted them and saved them, in defiance of the established norm. And so, regardless of who is in office, or on our money, we should be not give in to fear, real or imagined, of our neighbors. The Gospel will always demonstrate it’s worthiness, and speak to the deepest needs of the heart, if communicated faithfully.

Something equally helpful, I think, is that we should always try to better understand the positions of those we don’t agree with (ie. my example of Islam above). It will strengthen our own convictions and enable us to share our beliefs with one another in good faith. I’ve heard many dialogues fail in this regard, where the goal is not to gain mutual understanding, but to score points off of each other. (Or, even worse, play a zero-sum game.) You see Jesus resisting this style of debate in John 4, where he speaks with the Samaritan woman at the well. (See John 4:10,13,21-24.) She appears to bring up several arguments citing the contentions shared between Jews and Samaritans, in an effort to derail Jesus’ conversation with pointless whataboutisms. (This kind of talk also signals a lack of confidence in her own position, and in the presence of Jesus and his authority, she can only grouse and quibble.) Jesus doesn’t really engage the arguments but makes authoritative statements that reveal who she is and why she needs him. The fact that the beginning of John 4 states that he had to go to Sychar in Samaria shows also how he intentionally loved her in his own sovereignty. When he meets her, he also initiates the conversation, listens to her, understands her position, all while maintaining a chummy attitude about it. It’s a rare look at how Jesus engaged with those society had marginalized (in this case, a divorced woman living outside of the traditions of her community), and thankfully John recalled it in his memoir-gospel. We, likewise, should strive to emulate his example.

Some of this may be helpful (even encouraging) for non-Christians to hear, that we can all be amicable about understanding varying perspectives without feeling like we are immediately conceding a point from the start. Having this freedom however only makes sense if we are operating within a larger, authoritative Truth. This “capital ‘T’ truth” is something that is appealed to often in modern discussion, despite no one being able to agree on what defines this actual truth to begin with. (ie. “It’s just the right thin to do, you know?” or “It is wrong what Israel is doing to Palestinians.”) How this post all started was me reflecting on a conversation about “what was true” about Muslims, but, without an authoritative Truth, how can we even say something is “true” with any certainty? In modern argumentation, two proponents face off on an issue, citing their own evidence and experiences, and those “in the audience” of culture ultimately decide the victor. Who’s to say though, in this situation, which idea is objectively correct? The default position to take would be to say that “truth” is culturally conditioned or determined by what is best for the “common good”. (Another explanation is that humans evolved to have ethics and morals as a survival tool, and natural selection favored populations that cooperated with each other.) Personally, I’m not sure I agree. There was indeed a time when slavery was the status quo, when conquering nations to exploit their resources was normative, when the will of a singular dictator trumped the value and worth of a human being. Rome’s Empire, the greatest civilization in human history, accommodated all these positions and even celebrated them. Today we can reflect as 21st century citizens and say with confidence that this wasn’t acceptable behavior, but how can we say that confidently if we subscribe to moral relativism? We know in our bones that slavery is wrong, but who says that it’s wrong? It could be said that Roman slavers were operating within the morals of their day, that the cruelty of slavery had some net benefit to society, enabled the production of goods or the construction of large civic buildings, which suggests that the ends justified the means. So, the blow is softened slightly, and maybe this excuses the behavior? But imagine discovering a hypothetical tribe, hidden from the modern world for thousands of years, that is really into punching babies, just because. I’m sure we would step in immediately and stop them, intervene in the name of modern sensibility. What though drives our instinct to say that this is wrong? I could go on…

Tom Holland’s Dominion suggests that much of our modern sensibilities have been rooted originally in moral imperatives practiced by early Christians, and that that these imperatives became normative in the development of Western Civilization. The fact that he isn’t a Christian (or at least wasn’t one while writing Dominion) assuages my mind that this is just more shortsighted Christian Triumphalism. The book is really good though, especially the audio book variant that Holland records himself. I get the sense, especially in his epilogue, that he really wants to believe in Christianity, but just can’t bring himself to make that initial leap of faith. Maybe he has since, but I haven’t heard a definitive answer on the matter.

In conclusion, I do believe that understanding a circumstance, with all it’s historical complexity, requires tact and grace, but the reason why Christians can uniquely argue with this in mind is because we advocate for the authority of an absolute definition of truth, which stems from our understanding of God and the resulting assumptions we can make about the space-time reality. We can be winsome and charitable in our conversations, just like Jesus undoubtedly was, but we can also be confident that the Truth we subscribe to has the best explanatory power for who we are and what we are meant to be: to be small working models of new-creation.

Next
Next

Remembering Sir Patrick Stewart